The Science of Storytelling and why it’s time to add Story into your marketing

Story is how we understand what matters and how we give it meaning. Your marketing will be more impactful and powerful when you use stories to help your clients feel something. 

Storytelling is not new. In fact, one could argue that it’s the oldest form of marketing in the world. Stories have been used for centuries to shape and create culture, to form and sculpt meaning and to inform the masses in ways that are easy to understand. 

From Aesop and Ancient Greece to Walt Disney and Pixar, human beings gravitate towards stories well told. 

Why and how storytelling works and why you need it in your marketing strategy

But why do Stories work so well? 

Simply put, Stories work because of the way they impact our brain processes. They work because they make us feel something

And when we feel something? We create a thought – either positive or negative that we remember.

When we remember feelings and we associate those feelings and thoughts with someone or something – we are in a position to make a decision. 

And that is where the Storytelling leads directly into the sale. 

If you think about it, a sale is simply the act of asking your potential client or customer to make a decision. 

They either buy your thing or they don’t. 

The story is the way to put them in the buying state of mind. Or it can be a powerful tool to qualify the sale (on an emotional level) before it happens. 

How Stories impact our brains 

There was a study done in the 1980s on people who had traumatic brain injuries to the centre part of their brain – the part of their brain where we experience and create emotions. 

Medically, the patients fully recovered. They were able to get up and walk out of the hospital and breathe and perform basic bodily functions with no assistance. 

They were able to use rational thinking to do things like math and multiplication. They could read a book and they could drive a car. 

But they couldn’t make decisions about basic things like what to eat for lunch. 


Because the emotional centre in their brain was compromised. And that means so too was the part of the brain that makes decisions. 

Let’s reverse this for a moment. 

If we know that compromising or altering that part of the brain results in the inability to make a decision – then imagine what happens when we are able to activate it!

When we tell Stories that form emotions – that is precisely what we are doing. We are activating the emotional, decision making centre in our customers and clients brains. 

The chemical brain activities created by Storytelling

It’s only in the last few decades that neuroscience has started to really dive into the effectiveness of stories and why they impact our brains and decision making. 

But there is general scientific consensus that it’s a super power emotionally, if only for the chemicals released when we engage in the act of both telling and hearing a Story. 

Stories quite literally help us form memories

A report published in Science Daily explains how the tone in which a story is told (or received) can have a major lasting impact on how a person remembers not only the story itself, but also specific details related to that story. 

“Emotional voices produce changes in long-term memory, as well as capturing the listener’s attention. They influence how easily spoken words are later recognized and what emotions are assigned to them. Thus voices, like other emotional signals, affect listeners beyond the immediate present.”

Source: Springer Science+Business Media

Essentially, what the report says is that your audience will hear or read the words you write, but most of what they are remembering is the emotion they are associating with those words. The storytelling chemicals produced allow the brain to, in a way, by-pass the rational and enter the emotional centre much more quickly. 

The memories formed as a result of hearing Stories last longer and so do the emotional impacts. 

Maybe this is why it doesn’t take much for me to cry when I think about a story that happened 20 years ago that was particularly sad. Have you had that experience? It’s because we formed neuro-pathways that hightail us to those emotions. 

Stories help us to become aware of problems and solutions

While we are talking about chemicals, let’s talk about two of the key ingredients for decision-making – cortisol and oxytocin. 

Cortisol is our stress hormone. In fact, given our current pandemic, post-pandemic state, I’d hazard a guess that we are all in a state of elevated cortisol. It’s the chemical that is produced when we need to pay immediate attention to something stressful – like for example, if we are about to be hit by a bus or eaten by a tiger, or die in a pandemic. 

When something stressful happens, our cortisol levels immediately rise which helps us stay attentive to the moment (biologically so we can react to preserve life). 

This is the precise brain pattern that is stoked in pressure based sales.

Rising cortisol in our bodies is the emotional-chemical stew that is most closely associated with ‘the first sale’ or what marketers call ‘the top of the funnel’. Giovanni Rene Rodriguez wrote a great piece about our brains on storytelling for Forbes if you’d like to dig in further.

It’s why tactics like flash sales and timers work to get us to buy something. It’s why we can be pressured into ‘signing on the dotted line’ for a vehicle because the manager can’t guarantee that model will be available the next day. 

It’s because that environment, that STORY they are telling about scarcity of resources, activates the cortisol in our brains. 

(This is also why I’m much more a fan of permission based and empathy driven marketing. But we will get to that in a moment). 

Stories create empathy which allows us to feel safe saying yes. 

If cortisol is responsible for making us aware and alert to our emotions and surroundings, then oxytocin can be seen as the ‘closer chemical’ created through Story. 

As I was doing my research, I discovered an incredibly geeky and exciting fact that there’s now a label for this type of study called neuroeconomics- where the whole idea is to study the links between brain processes and decision making in an economic sense. 

The so-called father of neuroeconomics is Professor Paul Zak who has spoken at length about the role of oxytocin in how we ultimately make decisions that we feel good about. 

See Professor Paul Zak’s TEDTalk on Trust, Morality and Oxytocin here

In a nutshell, Zak shows how stories create oxytocin in our brains – which is the chemical responsible for EMPATHY. 

When we watch a movie like Forrest Gump, for example, our oxytocin levels skyrocket, creating an empathetic response to Tom Hanks in the role. That empathy is what allows us to not only like and love the character, but also identify with him on an emotional level (even if we are nothing like Forrest Gump at all). 

In studies conducted on oxytocin and dopamine (a close relative chemical), researchers found that subjects who heard stories or watched movies that produced elevated levels of oxytocin were much more likely to spend money and/or donate generously immediately thereafter. 

So you see mastering the art and craft of storytelling will be an invaluable tool for your marketing. It’s the seat of emotion and it’s how we invite our clients and audiences closer to us and closer to a sale. 

Take the Free Training!

You are swirling around feeling like you’re wasting valuable time and money on content that just isn’t moving the needle.

Or worse yet, you’re spending hours Googling solutions instead of actually creating content that will help you connect to your clients.

Well, I’ve got you covered.

In this FREE TRAINING (that you can access RIGHT NOW!) I’m going to help you get beyond the blinking cursor and unlock The Content Growth Framework™.

This framework is based on my YEARS of working with clients to help them build 30-60-90 day strategic content plans that allow them to:

  • attract better clients
  • attract more clients
  • align their offers to their audiences
  • launch blogs, podcasts, live streams
  • work with brands to sponsor content

And much more!

Take the free training to Create your Time Saving Content Plan and Attract your Ideal Clients right here!

The Rest of the Story is a project of love and commitment to showing up on this site every day for 90 days; sharing honest opinions, thoughts and observations. Comments are welcome.

Erin Trafford Incorporated is located on sacred land that has been the site of human activity for over 12,000 years. We are in Mi’kma’ki, the ancestral and unceded territory of the Mi’kmaq People, and we acknowledge them as the past, present, and future caretakers of this  land.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *